LinkBlog

Disclaimer

All content within Anxiety Insights is provided for general information only, and should not be treated as a substitute for the medical advice of your doctor or other health care professional.

Anxiety Insights is not responsible or liable for any diagnosis made by a reader based on the content of this website.

Anxiety Insights is not liable for the contents of any external internet sites listed, nor does it endorse any commercial product or service mentioned or advised on any of the sites.

Always consult your doctor if you are in any way concerned about your health.

Meta-analysis disputes CBT effectiveness

« H E » fulltxt :: email

posted Monday, 29 June 2009

Hélène Murphy

Research co-led by Professor Keith Laws at the School of Psychology, University of Hertfordshire, UK, concludes that Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) is of no value in schizophrenia and has limited effect on major and bipolar depression.

The meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials has been published online in the journal Psychological Medicine.

The paper reviews the use of CBT in schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and major depression. The results of the review suggest that not only is CBT ineffective in treating schizophrenia and in preventing relapse, it is also ineffective in preventing relapses in bipolar disorder. The review also suggests that CBT has only a weak effect in treating clinical depression, but it has a greater effect in preventing relapses of this disorder.

The authors focused particularly on methodologically rigorous trials that compared CBT to a 'psychological placebo' and also investigated the impact of 'blinding', i.e. whether or not the people who assessed the patients knew if they were receiving active treatment or not. Both factors are considered essential before a drug treatment is approved for use in psychiatric disorders.

The authors noted that not a single trial employing both blinding and psychological placebo has found CBT to be effective in schizophrenia and surprisingly few well-controlled studies of CBT in depression.

"The results of this review are important because in March NICE (National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence) re-approved CBT for use in all people with schizophrenia. The Government is also investing millions of pounds to provide CBT for depression and anxiety in 250 dedicated therapy centers across England," said Professor Laws. "Yet the evidence here is that the effectiveness of this form of therapy may be less than previously thought, to the point of being non-existent in schizophrenia."

Lynch D. Laws KR, McKenna PJ. Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials. Psychol Med. 2009; doi:10.1017/S003329170900590X [Abstract]

Comment:

CBT is probably a more effective anxiety and depression treatment than these findings suggest, but not nearly as good as some proclaim. Perhaps the major impediment is human nature. CBT, and similar psychotherapies such as Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) can require more ongoing effort than many patients are willing to devote, especially once they begin to feel well.

tags: clinical depression cognitive behavior therapy

links: digg this del.icio.us technorati reddit

comments

Action-potential

Wave of electrochemical activity generated by the flow of positively charged ions across the neuronal membrane which causes a neuron to 'fire'
- Click page link for more information -

Affective disorders

Mental disorders characterized by dramatic changes or extremes of mood - depression, mania, or both - including depression, bipolar disorder (manic depression), and schizo affective disorders.
- Click page link for more information -

Alleles

An alternative form of a gene (one member of a pair) that is located at a specific position on a specific chromosome.
- Click page link for more information -

Amygdalae

Two almond-shaped groups of neurons - there is one amygdala (Greek for almond) in each brain hemisphere. They have the primary role in processing and storing memories of emotional reactions.

Part of the Limbic System the amygdalae trigger an instant fear reaction to perceived threats, real or imagined.
- Click page link for more information -

Anterior cingulate cortex

Involved in empathy, emotions, cognitive control (attention, conflict monitoring during information processing) and plays a role in stimulus reinforcement learning and reward-guided selection of actions.

Also controls autonomic functions such as heart rate and blood pressure in the context of current behavior.
- Click page link for more information -

Autonomic arousal

Arousal of the autonomic nervous system which regulates many bodily functions and produces the physical symptoms of stress including the 'fight-or-flight' response.

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor

Protein required for the growth and survival of nerve cells during development, and for maintenance of adult nerve cells. Studies have shown that some neurotrophic factors can trigger regrowth of damaged nerve cells and stimulate growth and differentiation of new neurons in the hippocampus (neurogenesis).
- Click page link for more information -

Client-centered therapy

An approach to counseling and psychotherapy that places much of the responsibility for the treatment process on the client, with the therapist taking a non-directive role. Also called non-directive, person-centered, or Rogerian therapy.
- Click page link for more information -

Cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT)

Type of psychotherapy emphasizing the important role of thinking in how we feel and what we do.

Based on the concept that our thoughts cause our feelings and behaviors, not external things like people, situations, and events. The benefit of this fact is that we can change the way we think to feel/act better even if the situation does not change.
- Click page link for more information -
(Additional information in Ai side panel)

Clinical trial-Phase 1

The first test in humans of a new treatment to see if it is safe to use in people.
- Click page link for more information -

Compassion meditation

Based on Tibetan Buddhism techniques. Trains the mind to optimize the way it perceives relationships with others. Experienced practitioners are able to alter brain functioning to boost positive emotions, and enhance their immune systems.

Related to Mindfulness Meditation/Psychotherapy.
- Click page link for more information -

Corticotropin-releasing factor

A polypeptide hormone and neuro- transmitter involved in the stress response.

CRF hyper secretion is believed to contribute to hyperactivity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis in depressed patients. Hyper secretion has also been implicated in anxiety.
- Click page link for more information -

Cortisol

The most potent of the stress hormones. Synthesized from cholesterol by the adrenal glands. Increases blood pressure, blood sugar levels and suppresses immune function.
- Click page link for more information -

Cross sectional study

Epidemiological studies describing population characteristics which collect data at one point in time and then consider relationships between observed characteristics.. Because they don't look at time trends they cannot establish causes.

Cytochrome P450

Family of enzymes involved in the metabolic process. P450 liver enzymes metabolize most prescribed pharmaceutical and alternative medications.
- Click page link for more information -

Cytokines

A diverse group of signaling (messenger) molecules that mediate both the innate and adaptive immune response by regulating immunity, inflammation, and hematopoiesis (blood cell development).

Cytokines include the Interleukins, Interferons, Tumor Necrosis Factor Alpha and Transforming Growth Factor beta.

Cytokines are increasingly being used to treat cancers and viral infection, however, depression onset is a common side effect.
- Click page link for more information -

Dentate gyrus

Part of the hippocampus. Thought to contribute to formation of new memories and is one of the few brain regions where neurogenesis occurs. Has a role in recognizing the differences that make each place unique. Processing errors may play a role in deja vu.
- Click page link for more information -

Depression - Atypical

Defined by the ability to feel better temporarily in response to positive life events, plus any two of the following criteria: excessive sleep, overeating, a feeling of heaviness in the limbs and a sensitivity to rejection. Despite the name, it is actually the most common form of depression.
- Click page link for more information -

Depression - Clinical/Major

Characterized by a pervasive, unremitting low mood and loss of interest or pleasure in usual activities. In addition there are other physical and mental symptoms that may include fatigue, difficulty with concentration and memory, feelings of hopelessness and helplessness, headaches, body aches, and thoughts of suicide.
- Click page link for more information -

Dysthymia

Mood disorder within the depression spectrum. Considered a chronic depression, but less severe than major depression.
- Click page link for more information -

Emotion focussed therapy

A short term (8-20 session) psychotherapy based on helping the patient express emotions more easily and thus release unprocessed feelings and thoughts so that they may be dealt with openly.
- Click page link for more information -

Epigenetic inheritance

Process by which environmental factors like diet, stress, and ante/post-natal maternal factors can change gene function without altering the DNA sequence. These changes may remain through cell divisions and may also be passed down through multiple generations.
- Click page link for more information -

Fear extinction

Suppression of the expression of previously learned fear by repeated exposure to the object of fear without negative consequences. Also called 'inhibitory learning'
- Click page link for more information (

) -

First-degree relative

A parent, sibling or child of an individual.

Gamma-Aminobutyric Acid (GABA)

The major inhibitory neurotransmitter of the central nervous system. Dampens brain activity and promotes a state of calm.

An amino acid produced in the brain as a by-product of the Krebs glucose metabolism cycle which powers brain cells.

Note 1: Benzodiazepines (Valium® etc) do not increase brain GABA levels, but increase the sensitivity of GABA receptors.

Note 2: GABA does not normally penetrate the Brain-Blood-Barrier (the BBB tends to pull GABA from the brain into the blood stream (Kakee A, 2001)) so GABA supplements are, at best, expensive placebos.
- Click page link for more information -

Glial Cells

Support cells in the brain and spinal cord which provide physical and nutritional support for neurons, form the blood-brain barrier, clear dead cells and other debris, insulate neurons and, as part of the immune system, protect the brain from microorganisms.

Long thought not to conduct electrical impulses as the neurons do, there is growing evidence that they do modulate neurotransmission.

The largest group of cells of the central nervous system being between 50-100 times more abundant than neurons.
- Click page link for more information -

Haplotype

A group of alleles of different genes on a single chromosome that are so closely linked that they are usually inherited as a unit.
- Click page link for more information -

Heterozygote, Homozygote

Heterozygote: Any organism which has two differing forms of a particular gene for a specific trait, one inherited from each parent.

Homozygote: Any organism which has two identical forms of a particular gene for a specific trait, one inherited from each parent.

Because genes are either dominant or recessive, the genetic makeup (genotype) of an organism cannot always be determined by physical appearance alone.

Hippocampus

A seahorse shaped sheet of neurons laying next to the Amygdalae. Regulates emotions and short term memory.
- Click page link for more information -

Homologous

Anatomical structures that perform the same function in different biological species having evolved from the same structure in a shared ancestor species.

Hypothalamus

Regulates homeostasis, the maintenance of the body's status quo by producing hormones which control: Body temperature, Hunger, Moods, Sex drive, Sleep and Thirst.
- Click page link for more information -

Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis

A major part of the neuroendocrine system, comprising of the hypothalamus, pituitary gland and the adrenal glands, which controls reactions to stress and regulates many body processes, including digestion, the immune system, mood and emotions, sexuality, and energy storage and expenditure.
- Click page link for more information -

Interleukins - (IL-1 - IL-35)

Signaling molecules critical to the functioning of the immune system.

A recombinant form of IL-2 has been approved as an anti cancer drug and and may have anti viral properties. Changes in mental states including irritability, confusion, or depression are a known side-effect.
- Click page link for more information -

Interpersonal psychotherapy

Time-limited psychotherapy focusing on the interpersonal context and building interpersonal skills. Based on the belief that interpersonal factors may contribute heavily to psychological problems. Distinguished from other forms of therapy in its emphasis on the interpersonal rather than the intra psychic.
- Click page link for more information -

in vitro - in vivo

in vitro (Latin: within the glass) Experiments conducted with parts of an organism (often only a few cells) in a test-tube, petri dish, etc.

in vivo (Latin: within the living) Experiments conducted with more or less whole organisms.

Ion channel (ionopore)

Pore-forming proteins in cell walls which allow the movement of electrically charged ions across cell membranes that produce the electrical gradients responsible for nerve impulses.
- Click page link for more information -

Learned helplessness

A psychological state in which people gradually come to feel that they have no control over repeated adverse events and that failure is inevitable so become less willing to attempt tasks. A coping mechanism for surviving difficult or abusive circumstances. It offers a model to explain human depression, in which apathy and submission prevail.
- Click page link for more information -

Limbic system

Brain structure of the 'old' mammalian brain comprising the hippocampus, amygdalae, anterior thalamic nuclei, and the diencephalon in the forebrain. Regulates memory, and the emotions including fear, anger, and of sexual behavior.
- Click page link for more information -

Ligand

A molecule that is able to bind to and form a complex with a biomolecule to serve a biological purpose. Neurotransmitters are one type of ligand.

Longitudinal study

Research which studies a group of people over a period of time.

Lyme disease

Caused by spirochaete bacteria of the genus Borrelia which are found worldwide. It is called 'Chronic lymphocytic meningitis', 'Neuroborreliosis', 'Garin-Bujadoux syndrome' and 'Bannwarth's syndrome' in Europe.

In addition to symptoms typical of infectious disease - fever, chills, headache, rash etc, Lyme can also produce 'classic' anxiety symptoms including tingling or numbness of the extremities, disorientation, mental 'fog,' short term memory loss, fatigue, poor concentration and sleep disturbance, and may trigger depression. In some cases, these symptoms may not become apparent for many years after the initial infection.
- Click page link for more information -

Meta-analysis

Mathematical technique to amalgamating, summarizing, and reviewing previous quantitative research to arrive at one overall measure of treatment effect.

A weakness of the method is that sources of bias in the original research are not controlled by the method. A good meta-analysis of badly designed studies will still result in bad statistics.
- Click page link for more information -

Mindfulness

"Mindfulness is not a quick fix. The mindful approach encourages the person suffering from anxiety to move in close to their uncomfortable feelings, to watch the feelings of panic and racing heart, trembling hands, etc., with curiosity, openness and acceptance because, in fact, they are already there. This is a practice. We begin to become more tolerant of so-called negative states of mind, and then comfortable with them, then aware that everything changes constantly, including these states of mind. We begin to see anxiety for what it is: our body's adaptation to stress or to a thought and its subsequent attempt at communicating it to us."
Barbara Wilkinson,
certified trauma therapist
- Click page link for more information -

Mindfulness meditation/ psychotherapy

Mindfulness is the practice of becoming more aware of the present moment, rather than dwelling in the past or projecting into the future. It generally involves a heightened awareness of sensory stimuli (really noticing your breathing, feeling the sensations of your body, etc); and being 'in the now'. Principles may be combined with the concepts of Cognitive-Behavior Therapy (CBT) as Mindfulness-based Psychotherapy.
- Click page link for more information -

Narrative Exposure Therapy

Therapy developed to treat PTSD. Based on cognitive behavioral exposure therapy, it adapts classical exposure therapy to meet needs of traumatized survivors of war and torture.

Survivors are asked to describe what happened to them in great detail, focusing on what they saw, heard, smelt, etc, and their feelings and thoughts at the time. Initially, sessions are distressing, but as they are long enough to allow habituation, distress levels diminish towards the end and more and more details are recalled.
- Click page link for more information -

Neurogenesis

Process by which new neurons are generated after the postnatal stage of development. It appears to only occur in two areas of the brain, the hippocampus and the olfactory bulbs. Hippocampal neurogenesis is thought to counter anxiety and depression.
- Click page link for more information -

Neuropeptide

One of about 100 peptides including endorphins, enkephalins, oxytocin and vasopressin which mediate brain function by regulating gene expression, local blood flow and synaptogenesis. The neuropeptides Cholecystokinin, Substance P and Neuropeptide Y have been linked to anxiety and depressive disorders.
- Click page link for more information -

Neuroplastic

The brain's ability to reorganize itself by forming new neural connections.
- Click page link for more information -

Nucleus accumbens

Twin brain structures (one in each hemisphere) involved in reward, laughter, pleasure, addiction, fear, and the placebo effect.
- Click page link for more information -

Polymorphism

Natural variations in a gene, DNA sequence, protein, or chromosome.
-Click page link for more information-

Prefrontal Cortex

Area of the brain's frontal lobes involved in planning complex cognitive behaviors, the expression of personality and social behavior.
- Click page link for more information -

Prospective study

Tests a specific question, usually about how a specific exposure(s) affects a specific outcome(s) by recruiting appropriate participants and checks the outcomes over the following months or years.

Psychodynamic psychotherapy

Talking therapy used to help a person find relief from emotional pain. It is based on the theories and techniques of Freudian/Jung style psychoanalysis. However, practitioners don't necessarily accept the 'classical' psychoanalysis theory that emotional conflicts are primarily sexual in nature.

Receptor

Short-lived protein molecules embedded in the cell wall of neurons, especially of their synapses, to which neurotransmitters attach to initiate an action. Also called ´binding sites´
- Click page link for more information -

Receptor agonist

A chemical which is able to bind to receptors of a neurotransmitter and trigger the same biological response as that neurotransmitter.

Receptor antagonist

A drug that is so similar chemically to a neurotransmitter that it is capable of binding to a receptor for the neurotransmitter but which does not trigger the biological response of that neurotransmitter. By blocking its receptors the antagonist disrupts or inhibits the action of the neurotransmitter.

Retrospective study

Research using data on exposures and/or outcomes that have already been collected through medical records or as part of another study. Such data may not be as reliable as data collected prospectively, as it relies on the accuracy of records made at the time, and on people’s recall of past events, which can be inaccurate (referred to as recall bias).

Safety behavior

Behavior undertaken to reduce anxious thoughts, or to keep yourself 'safe' from imagined threats, or to hide your anxious state from others. Examples include constant monitoring of breathing or heart rate, shopping during quiet retail hours, taking precautionary tranquillizers "just in case," taking circuitous routes to avoid highways or bridges when driving, sitting close to exits, avoiding eye contact, playing with keys to hide trembling hands.

Seasonal affective disorder

A type of depression triggered by the seasons. The most common type is winter-onset depression (aka Winter blues), but some also regularly become depressed at the start of spring-summer.
- Click page link for more information -

Serotonin syndrome

A potentially life-threatening adverse reaction triggered by excess serotonergic activity in the central nervous system.
- Click page link for more information -

Serotonin transporter

A protein that transports the neurotransmitter serotonin across cell membranes.
- Click page link for more information -

Significant life events

Major stressors such as: death of relative (incl. miscarriage), friend, or pet; serious illness or injury, surviving a disaster; marriage, separation, divorce, relationship breakup; birth or adoption of a child; moving house or school; new job or promotion, unemployment or retirement;

Somatization disorder

Manifests as chronic, persistent complaints of varied physical symptoms that have no identifiable organic origin or basis. Often co morbid with other psychological disorders, particularly anxiety or mood disorders, plus irritable bowel syndrome and chronic pain. Occurs in 0.2% to 2% of females and 0.2% of males. Also known as Briquet's disorder.-Click page link for more information-

Sympathetic nervous system

The part of the nervous system which controls the body’s internal, involuntary processes including breathing, digestion, blood vessel tone, heart rate, etc. It also mediates the fight-or-flight response.

Subgenual cingulate

Brain region high in serotonin transporter-binding sites, with strong projections to the hypothalamus and brain stem. Modulates autonomic/neuroendocrine responses and neurotransmitter transmission during the neural processing of reward, fear, and stress. May be critical for modulating widespread behavioral changes mediated by the cortex. Volume is often decreased in mood disorders patients.

Also known as Brodmann area 25.
- Click page link for more information -

Synapses

Gaps between neurons through which "information" flows from one neuron (brain cell) to another.
- Click page link for more information -

Thalamus

Regulates sleep and awake states, arousal and awareness. Processes and relays sensory information to the cerebral cortex where they are experienced as sensations of pain, touch, or temperature. Damage to the thalamus can produce permanent coma.
- Click page link for more information -

Tumor necrosis factor-α

A cytokine which has wide range of pro inflammatory actions and induce necrosis (death) of tumor cells. Exacerbates chronic inflammatory autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis.

Blood plasma levels are raised in patients with depression. Research had shown that antidepressants reduce its expression.
- Click page link for more information -

White matter

Regions of the brain and spinal cord largely composed of nerve fibers (axons) sheathed in insulating myelin composed of lipids (fats) which give them their color.

White matter abnormalities (hyperintensities):
Damage to the myelin insulation. May be inherited, the result of disease (Multiple Sclerosis) or physical injury, stroke etc. Most brains accumulate some WM abnormalities with age.
- Click page link for more information -

««	Feb 2010					»»
S	M	T	W	T	F	S
	1	2	3	4	5	6
7	8	9	10	11	12	13
14	15	16	17	18	19	20
21	22	23	24	25	26	27
28

Calendar