
There is no evidence that chronic Lyme disease exists and if it does, the risks of prolonged antibiotic treatment outweigh any benefits, according to a review article published in the October 4 New England Journal of Medicine.
Lyme disease is the most common tick-borne infection in the Northern hemisphere. The disease is caused by bacteria, Borrelia burgdorferi (also B. afzelii and B. garinii in Europe), and typically manifests as a rash, while later - less common - symptoms may include meningitis, facial nerve palsy and arthritis. All of these conditions typically respond well to conventional antibiotic treatment, but a minority of patients subsequently complain of fatigue, musculoskeletal pain, and difficulty with concentration or short-term memory. These symptoms are usually mild and self-limited and are referred to as "post-Lyme disease symptoms." If they last longer than six months, they are called "post-Lyme disease syndrome."
The review article, written by Eugene D. Shapiro, M.D., of Yale and colleagues from other institutions, focused on what the authors refer to as the "imprecisely defined" condition "chronic Lyme disease." The authors note that this term is used by a small number of physicians to describe patients they claim have persistent B. burgdorferi infection, a condition that they say requires long-term antibiotic treatment and may be incurable.
"Although 'chronic Lyme disease' clearly encompasses post-Lyme disease syndrome, it also includes a broad array of illnesses or symptom complexes for which there is no reproducible or convincing scientific evidence of any relationship to B. burgdorferi infection," said Shapiro, who is professor of pediatrics, epidemiology and public and investigative medicine at Yale School of Medicine.
The article advises clinicians to tell their patients that there is no scientific evidence of "chronic Lyme disease," and to inform patients of the risks of unnecessary antibiotic therapy. The authors say that patients should also be thoroughly evaluated for medical conditions that could explain the symptoms.
"Explaining that there is no medication, such as an antibiotic, to cure the condition is one of the most difficult aspects of caring for such patients," said Shapiro. "Failure to do so leaves the patient susceptible to those who would offer unproven and potentially dangerous therapies."
Shapiro and his colleagues maintain that "chronic Lyme disease" is a misnomer, and the use of prolonged, dangerous, and expensive antibiotic treatments is not warranted.
Feder HM Jnr, Johnson BJB, O'Connell S, et al. A Critical Appraisal of "Chronic Lyme Disease" Engl J Med 2007 Oct 4; 357:1422.[Full text]
1. Kaplan RF, Jones-Woodward L, et al, (1999) "Neuropsychological Deficits in Lyme Disease Patients With and Without Other Evidence of Central Nervous System Pathology." Applied Neuropsychology, vol 6(1):p 3-11 [Abstract]
Fallon BA, Nields JA. (1994) "Lyme disease: a neuropsychiatric illness." Am J Psychiatry, vol 151(11):p 1571-83 [Abstract]
Fallon BA, Nields JA,Parsons, et al. (1993) "Psychiatric manifestations of Lyme borreliosis." J Clin Psychiatry, vol 54(7):p 263-8 [Abstract]
2. Logigian EL, Kaplan RF, et al, (1990) "Chronic neurological manifestations of Lyme disease." New England J of Medicine, vol 323:p 1438-44 [Abstract]
Went for years with undiagnosed Borrelia. Took an engorged tick into a
Texas Hospital to be told Texas didn't have Lyme Disease. This was August
of 1989. Had to stop working as an OB R.N. No tennis or jogging. Couldn't
walk much futher than my yard without great difficulty. In August of 1999
had brain aneurysm rupture and was in ICU, awakened every hr. on the hr.
However, hadn't felt so good in 10 years. They were infusing an antibiotic
called Rocephin to prevent infection. Soon after I left the hospital my
daughter called. She had to leave a medical class that morning because she
got so upset. The story being told was about a patient with vision
problems, dizzy spells, swollen joints, unexplained rashes, fast
degenerating arthritis, and tumor formations all over body, and a brain
aneuryzm rupture. The resident ordered a Borrelia test and he was positive
for Lyme Disease. This was the story my daughtered had watched with me.
She told me to ask to be tested because she remembered how upset I was the
morning her dad took the tick out of my head when she was a little girl. I
had the test and it was positive. I was given two more weeks of Rocephin
IV and I never felt better in my life. Six months later we had to move
back to Texas with the military and all the symptoms were coming back with
a new one-malaria. I saw an infectious disease doctor and he said I
couldn't possibly have malaria and I was already treated for Lyme. So I
must have Lyme Disease Syndrome. We came back to Co. and I started having
severe breathing problems. Many tests later I found my self on Oxygen
24/7. Oxygen saturation rates were very low and I had sleep apnea and
c-pap and bi-pap made the condition worse. My doctor referred me to a Lyme
Literate Clinic and I was found to be positive for two borrelia's and
babesia microti and babesia wa1. The Babesia causes a malaria type
ailment. A chest catheter was placed and I am infusing three IV's to this
day. The vision is strong, fatigue abated, fast degenerating arthritis has
stopped and I am out of the wheelchair. When I stop the antibiotics I go
back to Hell. Syphilis can be chronic, and is a much easier disease to
treat than the Borrelia's. We present the symptoms of someone with Gulf
War Syndrome, MS, ALS, Lupu, Alzheimers. I think it is probably the other
way around. The Borrelia is the cause of many of these diseases. Yale has
the patent on Borrelia, and I say shame on them for not coming forward. Do
any of the medical specialty groups think that those of us that are
fighting this disease want to spend thousands of dollars and put second and
third mortgages on our houses and spend hours a day infusing meds. for fun.
We are becomming a bigger and larger group and we are living this disease.
It is chronic. You all need to continue your studies and find out how
this disease morphs, and hides, to reappear again, to strike. If only
someone had offered me an oral antibiotic back in 1989 instead of "we don't
have Lyme Disease in Texas."
You may find this interesting Pam: Rash Judgement